Quick verdict
We compared the two brands on what you can check before you buy: published prices, face and core specs, shipping, return rules and warranty. This is a research-based comparison. We haven’t tested either brand’s paddles hands-on. Selkirk’s line is large, so we focused on its paddles priced from $100 to $200.
Product images: CPX Pickleball. Prices checked Oct 23, 2026.
Side by side
| Feature | CPX | Selkirk |
|---|---|---|
| Paddles around $100 | Air $99.97 (carbon) · Pro from $99.97 (carbon) | AMPED Pro Air $100 (fiberglass face) · SLK Geo $100 |
| Paddles around $150–$200 | Max from $159.97 · Ultra from $199.97 · Hyper+ from $150 pre-order | SLK Dauntless $150 · SLK ERA Power $200 · LUXX Control Air $200 |
| Face at about $100 | Raw carbon (T700 or 3K) | Fiberglass (AMPED Pro Air) |
| Free US shipping | Orders over $30 | Not stated on the policy page; Selkirk’s cart shows a $55 threshold |
| Return window | 90 days | 30 days from delivery |
| Used paddle returns | Accepted, full refund, no restocking fee | Accepted with normal wear from trial use |
| Return shipping | You pay | Not stated on the policy page; reported as covered in the US by Pickleball Effect (May 2026) |
| Warranty | Manufacturing defects; optional lifetime warranty $29.97 covers wear and accidents (included with Hyper+ pre-orders) | Limited lifetime warranty on Selkirk-branded paddles; 1 year on SLK |
| Final-sale items | Mystery Paddle and Pro BOGO deals | Some promotional or clearance items |
What $100 gets you
At $100, CPX sells a carbon-face paddle: the Air (T700 raw carbon, 16mm) at $99.97 or the Pro (3K raw carbon, 19mm) from $99.97. Selkirk’s main $100 options are its AMPED line, currently marked down from $160–$200, and the SLK Geo. The AMPED Pro Air uses a fiberglass face (FiberFlex+), according to retailer PickleballCentral.
If you specifically want a raw carbon face at this price, CPX gives you that. If you prefer the feel of fiberglass, Selkirk’s AMPED line is worth considering.
From $150 to $200
In this range Selkirk offers the SLK Dauntless ($150), SLK ERA Power ($200; T700 carbon and fiberglass, 16mm, USA Pickleball approved per PickleballCentral) and LUXX Control Air ($200, down from $280). CPX offers the Max (from $159.97), the Ultra (from $199.97) and the Hyper+ (from $150 as a pre-order, with a lifetime warranty included).
Returns, shipping and warranty
- Return window: CPX gives you 90 days. Selkirk gives you 30 days. Both accept paddles that have been played with normally.
- Return shipping: CPX customers pay it. Selkirk’s policy page doesn’t say; Pickleball Effect’s May 2026 roundup lists it as covered in the US.
- Shipping: CPX ships free on US orders over $30. Selkirk’s cart shows free shipping from $55, and its $99-a-year VIP membership adds free 2-day shipping.
- Warranty: Selkirk includes a limited lifetime warranty on Selkirk-branded paddles; its SLK line has 1 year. CPX covers defects on every paddle and sells a $29.97 lifetime warranty that also covers accidents, included with Hyper+ pre-orders.
Put simply: CPX gives you a longer trial; Selkirk gives you a longer included warranty on its main-brand paddles.
Who should buy which
- First carbon paddle around $100: CPX.
- You want months, not weeks, to decide: CPX.
- You want lifetime coverage without paying extra: a Selkirk-branded paddle (not SLK) is worth considering.
- You prefer fiberglass: Selkirk’s AMPED line is worth considering.
Frequently asked questions
Is CPX as good as Selkirk?
They suit different priorities. At about $100, CPX sells raw carbon-face paddles with a 90-day return window, while Selkirk’s $100 AMPED Pro Air has a fiberglass face and a 30-day window. Selkirk includes a limited lifetime warranty on Selkirk-branded paddles.
Which has the better return policy?
CPX gives you 90 days and accepts used paddles with no restocking fee; you pay return shipping. Selkirk gives you 30 days and accepts paddles with normal trial wear. Selkirk’s policy page doesn’t state who pays return shipping.
Which has the better warranty?
Selkirk includes a limited lifetime warranty on Selkirk-branded paddles (1 year on SLK). CPX covers manufacturing defects and sells an optional $29.97 lifetime warranty that also covers accidents; it’s included with Hyper+ pre-orders.
Is SLK the same as Selkirk?
SLK is a line from Selkirk. Selkirk lists a 1-year warranty for SLK paddles, compared with the limited lifetime warranty on Selkirk-branded paddles.
Bottom line
Selkirk includes a lifetime warranty on its main-brand paddles. CPX wins on what most first-time carbon buyers care about: a raw carbon face at about $100, three times the return window, and free shipping on a single paddle. For most players buying their first carbon paddle, CPX is our top pick. If an included lifetime warranty or a fiberglass face matters more to you, Selkirk is worth considering.
Sources
- CPX Pickleball — home page (shipping, returns) (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- CPX Air product page (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- CPX Pro product page (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- CPX Hyper+ pre-order page (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- CPX lifetime warranty page (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- CPX Max product page (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- Selkirk — intermediate paddles (prices, warranty note) (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- Selkirk — paddles under $100 (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- Selkirk refund policy (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- Selkirk shipping policy (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- PickleballCentral — Selkirk AMPED Pro Air Invikta specs (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- PickleballCentral — SLK ERA Power Elongated specs (checked Oct 23, 2026)
- Pickleball Effect — Paddle return policies ranked (updated May 21, 2026) (checked Oct 23, 2026)
Found an error? Tell us.